Unbundling Ownership and Control∗
نویسندگان
چکیده
Treating control as an asset that can be bought and sold, we introduce a model of the simultaneous and separable trading of ownership and control in a private information setting. The model provides a novel explanation for the prevalence and persistence of the separation of ownership from control in modern corporations: efficiency in the market for corporate control is more easily achieved when ownership is not concentrated in the hands of the manager. The central reason is that low managerial ownership reduces informational rents in the market for control. Using a mechanism design approach, we fully characterize the optimal mechanism for restructuring ownership and control. Under the optimal mechanism, corporations typically increase the number of shares of the incumbent manager if he remains in control, and give him a generous golden parachute that includes both stock and cash if he is deposed. By contrast, combining ownership and control is optimal only if agency costs are extreme.
منابع مشابه
Static vs. Dynamic Impacts of Unbundling – Electricity Markets in South America
Ownership unbundling and third party access are discussed as two options of unbundling in both the literature and political discussions. Focusing on the South American electricity sector, I contrast static and dynamic impacts of ownership unbundling and third party access regimes on customer prices. Substantially different results are found using dynamic rather than static analysis. In particul...
متن کاملRevisiting Electricity Liberalization and Security of Supply: Empirical Evidence
What effect does firm structure have on the product service quality on offer? We answer this question by empirically assessing the impacts of complete vertical separation, such as ownership unbundling, on the quality of service delivered by a liberalized network industry. Electricity distribution utilities in New Zealand are considered for this purpose. The results show robust evidence that own...
متن کاملRegulatory Objectives and the Intensity of Unbundling in Electricity Markets∗
Despite the positive effect electricity grids separated from generation and supply by ownership are expected to have on the level of competition in the non-network activities, several EU member states still adhere to a solely legally unbundled transmission grid. This choice might be induced by regulators focusing on objectives other than the promotion of consumer interests: theoretically analyz...
متن کاملNetwork investment under legal and ownership unbundling1
We consider an industry where an upstream rm determines the size of a network used by two downstream rms. We contrast ownership unbundling and legal unbundling, where the upstream rm maximizes its total pro t, including the pro t of its downstream subsidiary(ies), but does not discriminate between them. Furthermore, each downstream subsidiary maximizes its own pro t. We show that ownership s...
متن کاملOwnership Unbundling of Gas Transmis - sion Networks – Theoretical Background and Empirical
In this paper we analyse empirically the effects of ownership unbundling of gas transmission networks on the level of end-user prices. Based on a panel out of 29 OECD countries over 18 years we apply advanced approaches like the fixed effects estimator with robust standard errors and the corrected Least Squares Dummy Variable estimator (LSDVC) by Bruno (2005). Controlling for the oil price, the...
متن کاملImproving Competition in European Energy Markets Through Effective Unbundling
This Article is structured as follows: first, it summarizes the European approach to developing integrated and well-functioning electricity and gas markets, giving an overview of the opening of energy markets through Community legislation and the development of the current unbundling regime. It puts the European approach in perspective, outlining experiences with unbundling in the United States...
متن کامل